In addition to the specific guidance for each section, the following is general guidance.

  • All evidence may be subject to independent verification – false, inaccurate, or misleading evidence will lead to a probity concern being raised with the GMC
  • Documentation not in English – must be accompanied by a certified translation
  • Unintelligible evidence – it is the applicant’s responsibility to ensure that evidence uploaded is legible and clear
  • Completed achievements only - you can only claim on the basis of achievements completed at point of evidence upload
    • Includes publications accepted (no revisions required)
    • Posters/presentations must have been presented by the date of evidence upload
  • Related to field of medicine - all achievements should relate to the field of medicine (in its broadest sense), except where otherwise specified
  • Achievements in multiple domains – it is acceptable to use one achievement to score in two areas – for example, doing a presentation based on a publication; the only exception is that you cannot claim for a presentation on a quality improvement/audit project as this forms part of the scoring for the Audit section
  • Borderline evidence – applicants providing evidence that does not clearly meet the scoring criteria must justify why the evidence provided should be accepted

Domains

Please see the list of domains which you will be assessed against.

  • Years in Practice
  • Surgical Experience - Hand Trauma
  • Surgical Competence - Burn Surgery
  • Surgical Competence - Skin Cancer
  • Audit
  • Higher Qualifications Directly Related to Medicine
  • Publications
  • Presentations / Posters
  • Collaborative Research
  • Principal Investigator
Years in practice (Post Qualification)

Time in practice is the time between graduation from medical school and the day of interview.

Time spent on statutory leave (sick leave / maternity leave) and general military duties may be deducted provided that a written explanation is provided (you do not need to give a diagnosis). If you choose to deduct time spent on statutory leave or general military duties, then any achievements gained during the deducted period may not be included in your portfolio as evidence. For example, an applicant spent 2 years on general military duties and wishes to deduct these from their Years in Practice score – this is allowed, but means they cannot score for the audits they carried out during this period.

Applicants working less than full time may reduce their Years in Practice proportionally but must show their working. For example, an applicant qualified 8 years ago, but has spent 4 of these years working at 60% of full-time equivalent – their Years in Practice would be 4 + (4x0.6) = 6.4.

If you consider that there should be other reasons why your years in practice should be reduced, written evidence should be provided which will be assessed by the Lead Clinical Advisor. Any achievements gained during this period cannot be included in your portfolio as evidence.

Evidence required

  • All applicants: primary Medical Qualification (copy of degree certificate or equivalent), must include date, and name of awarding university/medical school
  • If applicable: explanation of statutory leave claimed
  • If applicable: part-time working calculation

Scoring

Years in practice Letter Score
<5 A 3
5.1 - 7 B 2
7.1 - 10 C 1
>10 D 0
Surgical experience / competence

Evidence required

  • All applicants: a verified* logbook should be included at the start of this section of evidence

* A verified logbook should be signed and dated on each page with a legible name and/or GMC number of the verifying consultant. Only a consultant (or international equivalent) may verify a logbook.

If the verifying consultant is not registered with the GMC, they should indicate their role and affiliation on the first page of the logbook, for example, "Dr Elizabeth Corday, Surgical Attending, Cook County Hospital, Chicago, USA".

Guidance on acceptable evidence

All applicants who have access to ISCP (i.e. all trainees based in the UK for 2 years or more) must use ISCP and present WBAs (DOPS or PBA) as evidence of experience and competence.
Applicants without access to ISCP must provide evidence of a greater number of cases via a validated logbook (see below).

Letters from consultants will not be accepted as evidence of ability to carry out procedures.

Only procedures for which you were the lead surgeon for the relevant part of the procedure can be counted (such as, P, PPT, PAT, STU, STS, not Assisted or Observed).

WBAs should be completed by the trainer who was present/supervising during the procedure.

Paper-based/scanned/copied WBAs completed by trainers not enrolled on ISCP will not be accepted (follow guidance for applicants without access to ISCP).

"Salami-slicing" of procedures is not allowed (for example, a 3 finger flexor tendon repair on one patient gives 1 WBA, not 3, but the associated nerve repair may be assessed separately).

Simulated cases (such as cadaveric courses) do not score in this section.

Consultants are those on the GMC Specialist Register at the time of the procedure/WBA.

Locum consultants will be considered equivalent to consultants provided they are not a trainee "acting up" on a temporary basis (annotate if necessary).

Experienced SAS doctors will be considered equivalent to consultants, provided this is justified by the applicant, for example, annotate as "Ms Carrie Weaver, Staff Grade in Plastic Surgery".

Trainees at any level are not considered equivalent to consultants (for example, ST8 fellow in hand surgery is still a trainee).

WBAs completed by anyone working below registrar level (for example, CST, CT3) will not be accepted as evidence of competence and may result in a probity concern being raised.

Applicants are reminded that level 3 and 4 are described in the ISCP as follows:

  • Level 3 – procedure performed with minimal guidance/without guidance
  • Level 4 – procedure performed fluently without guidance or intervention

 

Surgical competence - Hand Trauma 

Make a selection that describes your level of competence in this section, by considering the examples shown below.

A B C D E
Nailbed repair1

Extensor tendon repair (any zone)

Hand fracture fixation2

Flexor tendon repair (zone I-II only) Mixed nerve repair3

Evidence required

  • All applicants: summary logbook for the procedures in this section
  • All applicants: 3 WBAs at the level at which you are claiming competency, of these all 3 must be signed by a consultant4 and be at level 3 or 4 or 6 cases in a verified logbook (if no access to ISCP)
  • All applicants: 3 WBAs at the level below which you are claiming competency, of these all 3 must be signed by a consultantα and be at level 3 or 4 or 6 cases in a verified logbook (if no access to ISCP)
  • 1A nailbed repair itself does not score, but provides the "level below" for extensor tendon repair
  • 2A hand fracture fixation is with a K wire, screw, or plate (not a cast/splint) of any carpal bone, metacarpal, or proximal/middle phalanx (distal phalanx excluded)
  • 3A mixed nerve has both motor and sensory elements such as the median and ulnar nerves, and the radial nerve at the elbow; this excludes the superficial radial nerve
  • 4See notes above on who may be considered equivalent to a consultant for signing WBAs
Surgical competence - Burns

Make a selection that describes your level of competence in each section, by considering the examples shown below.

A B C D E
No experience Excise & SSG <5% TBSA of a burn1 Excise & SSG 5-19% TBSA of a burn1 Excise & SSG 20-49% TBSA of a burn1 Excise & SSG >50% TBSA of a burn1

Evidence required

  • All applicants: summary logbook for the procedures in this section
  • All applicants: 3 WBAs at the level at which you are claiming competency, of these all 3 must be signed by a consultant2 and be at level 3 or 4 or six cases in a verified logbook (if no access to ISCP)
  • All applicants: 3 WBAs at the level below which you are claiming competency,of these all 3 must be signed by a consultantα and be at level 3 or 4 or six cases in a verified logbook (if no access to ISCP)

1In this section, the percentages refer to the TBSA that you personally excised and grafted (not the TBSA of the whole burn).

To score in this section, the burn must have been skin grafted (includes allograft) or covered with a skin substitute such as Integra, Matriderm, or BTM (not just dressings).

Please annotate your WBAs/logbook accordingly, for example, "I excised 10% TBSA of a 70% burn and covered this with Integra".

Non-burn wounds do not score in this section (for example, pre-tibial laceration, necrotising infection, toxic epidermal necrolysis).

2See notes above on who may be considered equivalent to a consultant for signing WBAs.

Surgical competence - Skin Cancer 

Make a selection that describes your level of competence in each section, by considering the examples shown below.

A B C D E
No experience Excise skin malignancy1 and direct closure Excise skin malignancy1 and FTSG Excise skin malignancy1 and flap closure2

More complex flap3

Evidence required

  • All applicants: summary logbook for the procedures in this section
  • All applicants: 3 WBAs at the level at which you are claiming competency, of these 2 must be signed by a consultant3 and be at level 3 or 4 or 6 cases in a verified logbook (if no access to ISCP)
  • All applicants: 3 WBAs at the level below which you are claiming competency, of these 2 must be signed by a consultant3 and be at level 3 or 4 or 6 cases in a verified logbook (if no access to ISCP)

See notes above on who may be considered equivalent to a consultant for signing WBAs.

1Skin malignancy means a neoplastic lesion, including BCC, SCC, melanoma, or Merkel cell carcinoma, where a margin needs to be considered and marked.

2Local flaps include bilobed flap, rhomboid flap (and square peg), H flap.

3Does not need to include excision. More complex flaps include cheek rotation flap, scalp rotation or transposition flap, keystone flap, fasciocutaneous flap, pedicled flap.

Higher qualifications directly related to medicine

Please select the highest option relevant to you, with E being the highest score and A being the lowest. For example, 1-E will score higher than 2-C.

  A B C D E
1 None BSc awarded (intercalated degrees do not score)  Masters with less than 1 year of research awarded  Full time1 masters with 1-2 years of research awarded Full time1 MD with >2 years of research awarded
or PhD awarded
2 - Masters with less than 1 year of research in progress Full time1 masters with 1-2 years of research writing or submitted
(lab phase or equivalent complete)
Full time1 MD with >2 years of research, or PhD, writing or submitted
(lab phase or equivalent complete)
-
3 - Full time1 masters with 1-2 years of research
(lab phase or equivalent in progress)
Full time1 MD with >2 years research or PhD, lab phase or equivalent in progress - -
4 - - BDS or equivalent awarded
MRCP or equivalent awarded
PG Cert Medical Education3 awarded
FDS or equivalent awarded -

Evidence required

  • Applicants with qualification awarded: copy of qualification certificate, including date and awarding institution description of work, including number of hours per week and proportion of research vs study
  • Applicants with qualification in progress: confirmation of course enrolment and commencement of study/research description of work, including number of hours per week and proportion of research vs study, if applicable, confirmation of lab work completion or thesis submission

Directly related to medicine includes anatomy, biomedical science, pharmacology, and psychology. Other qualifications may be accepted but a comprehensive description of the course should be provided by the applicant for consideration by the assessors.

1Full time is considered to be equivalent to 37.5 hours per week. Part-time (less than 37.5 hrs/wk) courses should be included in the "less than 1-year research" group (1C or 2B)

2A PGCME may be counted if it involves at least a year of part-time study (supply written details).

3A PGCME may be counted if it involves at least one academic year of part-time study (supply written details). If your PGCME was not awarded by a degree-awarding body, provide a detailed description of the course to confirm equivalence. (see Check if your university or college can award a degree: Overview - GOV.UK ) 

This section is to score applicants that have taken extra time to complete a higher degree, awards that are given on completion of standard training will not be included in this section (for example Masters in Surgery/Medicine do not score if they are equivalent to MRCS in the country where they are awarded).

Intercalated degrees do not score.

MRCS, FRCS and FRCS(Plast) do not score.

Audit

Please make a selection from the list.

Audit Letter Points
Little or no evidence  A 0
An audit relating to plastic surgery1 as primary author, presented at an audit meeting but full cycle not completed  B 1
A full cycle audit relating to plastic surgery1 where both audit and re-audit are completed by the applicant as primary author, and presented by the applicant at an audit meeting C 2
Extra point available for an audit that the assessors feel has made a significant impact to patient care - 3

Evidence required

  • All applicants: evidence of first cycle data collection and presentation description of intervention/change evidence of second cycle data collection and presentation
  • Applicants with access to ISCP: either an AoA (Assessment of Audit) for each cycle or an AoA confirming that both cycles have been undertaken by the applicant
  • Applicants without access to ISCP: written evidence from your supervising consultant confirming that both cycles have been undertaken by the applicant

1Related to plastic surgery does not include general audits (such as VTE risk assessment, medical records audit, handwashing audit) even when performed on a plastic surgery ward.

 

 

 

 

Publications

Applicants are asked to provide evidence of your four highest-scoring papers. Your overall score will be based on the total of the impact factor scores for the four papers.

Principal authorship will get 100% of impact factor, giving the "impact factor score". Any other authorship will get 50% of impact factor, giving the "impact factor score".

All papers must be PubMed cited and have an impact factor. Impact factors will be taken from JCR Clarivate 2025 list (even if the paper was published in a previous year).

If co-principal authorship is claimed then it will need to be evidenced from the journal itself. No one below 2nd author will be considered principal unless you are the senior author.

Collaborative papers do not score in this section and are dealt with below.

Only full paper publications will score in this section.

Other publication formats such as letters to the editor, short communications, case reports and technical tips will be assessed on their merit and may be counted at 25% if the publication has useful clinical content, and only if you are the principal author.

For example, an applicant has provided 4 papers:

  1. 1st author publication in JPRAS, impact factor 2.74 – 100% of impact factor = 2.74
  2. 3rd author publication in Annals of Surgery, impact factor 12.97 – 50% of impact factor = 6.5
  3. 2nd author publication in Cureus, impact factor 1.15 – 50% of impact factor = 0.575
  4. 1st author publication in European Journal of Plastic Surgery, impact factor 0.55 – 100% of impact factor = 0.55

Total score is 2.74 + 6.5 + 0.575 + 0.55 = 10.365 which would give an overall Qpercom score of 3.

Total impact score of 4 papers Qpercom Score 
0 0
0.01 – 2.50 1
2.51 – 7.50 2
7.51 – 12.50 3
12.51 – 17.50 4
>17.51 5

Evidence required

  • All applicants: full PubMed citation for each paper
  • All applicants: impact factor score calculation as illustrated above
Presentations / posters

Applicants are asked to provide evidence of up to four posters or presentations as first author that you have presented at a national or international meeting.

Presentations/posters will not score if you are anything other than first author/presenter.

A presentation/poster will only score if it has been presented by the date of evidence upload.

National or international means a poster or presentation presented to a formal UK-wide, Scottish, Welsh, Northern Irish, or international body such as BAPRAS, BSSH, BBA, BAHNO, ASGBI, FESSH, Celtic BAPRAS, Welsh Surgical Society.

Specifically, RSM, Alcock Society, NPRAS, and their equivalents are not counted as national or international.

Trainee-led meetings such as those organized by ASiT and PLASTA do not score. 

National or international means a poster or presentation presented to a formal UK-wide or international body such as BAPRAS, BSSH, BBA, BAHNO, ASGBI, or FESSH.

Where there is a UK equivalent, bodies or organisations from Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland will be considered as national.

The only exception to this is the Celtic BAPRAS meeting which, as per guidance last year, will be recognised as a national meeting for the purpose of this section.

There are a number of meetings and organisations that badge themselves as national or international but are not considered to have equivalent peer review and scrutiny of presentations to meet the standard to score in this section. The assessors will consider each of these on its merits.

Please be aware that an individual piece of work can only be scored once within the presentation and poster section, irrespective of the number of times it was presented.

Assessors will want to see evidence that your presentations/posters are substantively different to one another.

Evidence required

  • All applicants: for each presentation/poster
    • name, date, location of meeting
    • confirmation of presentation, confirming you as first author/presenter, for example, slide presentation showing your name, poster showing author list
Collaborative research

1 point will be given if the applicant has participated in two collaborative papers.

Evidence required

  • All applicants: evidence of inclusion on the author lists of 2 collaborative papers
Principal investigator

1 point will be given if the applicant has been Principal Investigator in a formal NIHR-approved, or equivalent, trial.

Evidence required

  • All applicants: evidence of participation as Principal Investigator

Page last reviewed: 19 November 2026
Next review due: 19 November 2028